Case law · Appeals court · Federal

Garcia Jay Wright v. George Collins, Warden, Maryland Penitentiary Dr. Berry Officer Larry Donnell

Decided
January 7, 1985
Docket
84-6001
Status
Published
Jurisdiction
Federal

Cited 4,454 timesNo negative treatment found in this library

What later courts said

  • holding that disagreements between an inmate and physician over the inmate’s medical care do not state a §1983 claim unless there are exceptional circumstances — Nabawi v. Young (2022)
  • holding that “[d]isagreements between an inmate and a physician over the inmate’s proper medical care” are not sufficient to raise an Eighth Amendment claim — Butler v. Northern Neck Regional Jail (2020)
  • holding that an inmate’s mere disagreement with medical providers about the proper course of treatment does not support an Eighth Amendment cause of action. — Al-Haqq v. Smith (2025)

Each line is a later court’s own words about this case, not a summary. Read the opinion before relying on it.

How the opinion begins

ERVIN, Circuit Judge:

Appellant Garcia Jay Wright is an inmate at Maryland Penitentiary. He brought this action under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 against the warden, a correctional officer, and the chief medical officer of Maryland Penitentiary. Wright alleges that a variety of actions by these prison officials violated his constitutional rights. The district court referred the case to a magistrate who recommended that a motion by appellees for summary judgment be granted. The district court granted Wright an extension of time to file objections to the magistrate’s report. No objections were filed. The district court adopted the magistrate’s recommendations and denied a subsequent request by Wright for an additional extension of time to file objections. Wright then moved to amend his complaint and to vacate the district court’s judgment. Both motions were denied. Wright now appeals from the grant of summary judgment.

On this appeal we must decide, first, whether Wright has waived his right of appeal due to his failure to file objections to the magistrate’s report under 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1). If Wright’s appeal has not been waived, we must consider (1) whether res judicata bars consideration of his challenge to the constitutionality of prison conditions due to the previous judgment involving conditions at Maryland Penitentiary in Nelson v. Collins, 455 F.Supp. 727 (D.Md.1978), aff'd in part and remanded sub nom. Johnson v. Levine, 588 F.2d 1378 (4th Cir.1978); vacated in part and remanded, Nelson v. Collins, 659 F.2d 420 (4th Cir.1981); and (2) whether the district court erred in granting summary judgment to the defendants. We affirm in part and reverse in part and remand the case for further proceedings.

Statutes cited

Cite this

Garcia Jay Wright v. George Collins, Warden, Maryland Penitentiary Dr. Berry Officer Larry Donnell, 766 F.2d 841 (1985)

Read the full opinion

Free account needed

Reading the library on this site uses your account’s daily calls, the same as the connector and the API. The Free plan needs no card. Calls a day on each plan.